top of page
  • bill3766

Lawsuit Challenges Administration Requirements For Fixed Indemnity Health Plans

On May 21, 2024, ManhattanLife Insurance and Annuity Company, along with Paschall Health Insurance and its owner, filed a lawsuit in Texas to block the Biden Administration from enforcing new notice requirements for fixed indemnity policies. This lawsuit challenges the administration's recent regulations designed to enhance consumer protections under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). These regulations, finalized in March 2024, require expanded disclosures for short-term and fixed indemnity insurance policies to ensure consumers are aware that these plans do not provide comprehensive health insurance. The plaintiffs argue that the regulations exceed statutory authority and could negatively impact their business. The case underscores ongoing legal and political debates surrounding health insurance reforms and consumer protection measures. Click here for article.

  • Background on Regulation: In March 2024, the Biden Administration issued final regulations to increase transparency and consumer awareness for short-term and fixed indemnity insurance, requiring new disclosures that these plans do not offer comprehensive health coverage.

  • Plaintiffs' Argument: The plaintiffs contend that the notice requirements surpass the statutory limits for "excepted benefits" under federal law, arguing the mandates are misleading and will decrease sales by incorrectly stating that fixed indemnity plans are not health insurance.

  • Defendants' Position: The tri-departments (Health and Human Services, Treasury, and Labor) defend their regulatory authority, asserting that the new requirements are within their powers to ensure consumer protections function as Congress intended and address changes in market conditions.

  • Political and Legal Context: The lawsuit is part of a broader struggle over health insurance regulation, with significant political division. Republican leaders criticize the regulations as overly restrictive, while Democratic leaders support them as necessary for consumer protection. The outcome of this and other lawsuits will significantly impact the implementation of the Biden Administration's health policies.

0 views0 comments


bottom of page